Having been in operation in Palm Beach, Florida since 2017, Fabrikant & Miller focuses almost entirely on purchasing fine jewelry and luxury watches rather than selling new pieces. In a highly desirable, luxurious place like Palm Beach, where estate collections, inherited diamonds, and designer jewelry change hands with some frequency, this esteemed jeweler occupies a very specific niche.
They’re not a retail boutique in the usual sense and do not chase walk-in traffic for flashy new merchandise. Instead, the business centers on buying fine jewelry, diamonds, watches, gold, silver, and related items from private sellers who prefer a highly discreet selling process.
Peter Fabrikant comes from a New York jewelry family with roots that stretch back generations in the diamond district. He spent years working with estate pieces and building contacts that extend well beyond South Florida. Craig Miller brought more than four decades of experience from senior roles at houses such as Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels, GRAFF, Bulgari, and Tourneau, with time spent in Palm Beach, New York, and Washington, D.C. Together they opened the location in Via Newsome at 325-B Worth Avenue, choosing the address for its mix of privacy and proximity to the island’s established luxury corridor.
The range of luxury jewelry items they examine is pretty broad. Diamonds of various shapes, sizes, colors, and clarities form a core part of the work; both partners are described as GIA-trained diamond appraisers with long practice grading stones even when certificates are absent. Signed pieces from names like Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels, Tiffany & Co., David Webb, and Buccellati appear regularly, as do unsigned fine jewelry from Art Deco through mid-century and later periods. Luxury watches from Rolex, Patek Philippe, Audemars Piguet, and similar makers are also accepted, along with gold and silver in various forms, American coins with numismatic value, and certain objects d’art. However, modern costume jewelry falls outside of their interest.
Their buying process itself is pretty straightforward and very low-pressure by design. South Florida locals to international sellers can easily schedule a private appointment or stop by during weekday hours, typically 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., with weekends available by arrangement. Their fine jewelry evaluations are free and carry no obligation to sell. The discussion with sophisticated sellers usually covers condition, current market demand, provenance where it matters, and design quality rather than simple melt value alone. When an offer is accepted, a payment follows quickly—often in the same day by check drawn on a local JP Morgan Chase account or by wire for larger amounts. The global buyers network the partners maintain is frequently cited as the reason offers can exceed what a purely local scrap buyer might present.
Palm Beach and the wider South Florida luxury market creates particular conditions for this kind of business. Seasonal residents, longtime island families, and collectors from nearby coastal towns often hold pieces that have sat in safes or drawers for years. Some items carry strong sentimental weight, yet others simply no longer fit a current lifestyle. In that type of setting, the combination of technical knowledge and a private setting carries weight with sellers. Their public feedback remains relatively limited in volume but tends to note knowledge of the material, clear explanations, and an absence of high-pressure tactics. Ratings that appear on review aggregators hover in the mid-to-high range based on a fairly modest number of entries. But remember, they tend to attract discreet sellers who wish to keep their transactions private. Regardless, they’ve helped thousands of luxury jewelry sellers offload their items with exceptional payouts.
Several practical points tend to stand out clearly for anyone considering a sale. Having proper documentation or certificates helps but is not always required, given the grading experience on site. Also, the timing can influence your outcomes because market demand for specific styles or stones shifts frequently. However, larger collections or more unusual pieces may benefit from the wider buyer network this jeweler maintains. Discretion always remains a consistent theme in how they operate, which aligns with the preferences of many sophisticated sellers in this prestigious part of Florida.
Fabrikant & Miller does not position themselves as the only jewelry buyer option along Worth Avenue or in the broader region. Auction houses, other private buyers, and online platforms exist and serve different seller needs too. What they offer is a more focused buying service grounded in long industry tenure, a physical presence on the island, and an emphasis on direct, private, and discreet transactions. For any sellers weighing those factors against their own pieces and unique circumstances, their location and background provides a pretty clear reference point within South Florida’s local luxury market.
